By Teymoor Nabili
Certainly Iran's hardline clerics seem convinced that the founding principles of their country's government will replicate themselves in Egypt; no doubt, also, that there are western politicians for whom the name Muslim Brotherhood conjures up all manner of nightmares and deja-vu.
But Geneive Abdo at Inside Iran argues persuasively that the analogy does not hold.
Despite the fact that Iran's revolution also began with a broad coalition of discontents, not muslim hardliners alone, she says:
[...] the driving forces of the revolution were Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, who was clearly the charismatic figure leading the way, and his cadre of clerics, some of whom are still the pillars of the regime today in Iran. There are no clerics or even leaders within the Brotherhood positioning themselves as stand-ins for Mubarak.
That sounds about right - up to a point.
Certainly the voices of Iran's middle classes and bazaaris, and of the leftist students who played such a large part in toppling the Shah, did retreat into the background as the Ayatollahs cemented their grip, and certainly no real leader has emerged from the ranks of Egypt's Muslim Brotherhood, despite the opportunity.
However, these are early days, so it may be worth finessing the analogy a little, if only as an exercise in future-proofing.
It could be that, for Iran and others in the region, a full blown replica of Iran's revolution is not necessary for now, and they're quite happy believing that the priorities of The American Century are being so widely challenged and, in many ways, rejected.
As Ayatollah Khatami very carefully articulated, his vision is not specifically of an Islamic Republic of Egypt but "a new Middle East, based on Islamic principles."
Teymoor Nabili is an award-winning presenter and correspondent based in Doha.
|< Prev||Next >|
Other articles in Analysis
Celebrating United Jerusalem - in Sheikh Jarrah 28 May 2011
Morocco's uphill struggle for media reform 26 May 2011
Congress to Palestinians: Drop dead 25 May 2011
Mission impossible: Keeping Israel happy 23 May 2011
Mother of the Revolution 22 May 2011
Obama, Netanyahu and the 1967 borders 21 May 2011
A View From the Opposition 19 May 2011
Obama gives up, AIPAC wins 18 May 2011
Of Humans and Rights 15 May 2011